Head to head
Garmin R50 vs SkyTrak ST MAX
Two side-of-ball units at very different prices. The R50's built-in simulator screen is the main reason to spend more.
The short answer
There's no universal winner; it depends on your room and how you play.
Buy the R50 if
you want an all-in-one unit that plays courses on its own touchscreen, indoors or at the range.
Buy the ST MAX if
you'll use a projector or PC anyway and would rather spend the difference on the rest of the bay.
Specifications compared
Highlighted rows differ. A dot marks the better figure where numbers compare fairly.
Strengths and weaknesses
Garmin Approach R50
Strengths: Built-in 10-inch touchscreen simulator; no PC needed; Indoor and outdoor; Impact video
Weaknesses: Only some metrics itemized publicly; Course library requires a membership; 4-hour battery
SkyTrak ST MAX
Strengths: Club data without stickers; Low depth requirement; No subscription required to play
Weaknesses: One-year warranty; Side placement means moving it for left-handed golfers; 1 s shot delay
We haven't hands-on tested these products. Rankings use published specifications and the weights on our methodology page. Commission never changes a score or a position.
Specifications checked 9 Nov 2026; see each product page for sources.
Plan the whole setup
Build your simulator around your room
Pick a launch monitor, mat, screen, enclosure, projector, software and computer. We check each one against your room and show the full cost.